or,
Let's All Go to Camp!I watched
Jesus Camp with the purest of intentions to not blog about it. It clearly doesn't fit into my model of
righteous hexitude. But what I saw there was surprising, and not in a way that I was ready to be surprised. So I'm going to write about it, but I'm going to try my best to turn it around into something that we can all learn from instead of simply getting disgusted by. If you do feel a strong urge to be disgusted, there are flight discomfort bags in the pouch on the seat in front of you.
Five minutes into the film I made a decision:
I am going to see myself in these people. In retrospect, that may have been a bad idea, but I really wanted to try to understand them and their cause. I wanted to see these people as children of the Goddess, expressions of Spirit, or whatever you want to call it. I am them and they are me and God is a person just like we... uhm... are.
Perhaps because of this particular viewpoint, I noticed that what the evangelicals in this film had done is take some of the best parts of Christianity, some of the best parts of Spiritualism, and some of the most powerful practices of ecstatic pagan ritual and
warped them beyond all recognition in the name of an angry God. My jaw dropped when I saw chanting, intense tears, ecstasy, and what I can only call mediumship standing alongside each other and all riled up by scripture.
Regardless of doctrine and practice, I did see a few common threads between these people and our community. We want our children to be safe, strong, and respected for what they believe, but we (and the children) know that this respect will not always be afforded. We want to save the world from itself - in their case, bringing people to Jesus and away from sin; in our case, bringing humanity into ecological balance and creating a sustainable society. We feel ridiculed for our faith but still stand strong within it - they seem to think that Bush is helping them, though.
This is all well and good in a pluralistic culture. Unfortunately, pluralism is not part of their particular view. It has been replaced by spiritual militarism.
At this point, the only way that I know how to fight this type of theocratic thinking is to avoid getting swept up in it myself. There are more concrete actions to be taken, but I agree with this
quote from Thorn's blog:
Anaar said yesterday that magic workers cannot hope to change the world until we can learn to get along with each other. Yeah. That is our work. Get clean inside, and get clean in our immediate relationships. Then maybe the polis can become a better place to live all around.
So it's time for some personal inventory, for myself and, I think, for all of us. Get out your pen and start checking things off the list. Here are the lessons I gleaned from
Jesus Camp, all of which are things to avoid, but not to ignore.
IndoctrinationI'm not sure I can think of any pagans who are pro-indoctrination, per se. What I have seen is de facto indoctrination - the kind that is sneaky, snarky, and gnarly. I'm talking about coven leaders who discourage or forbid their members to study outside of the coven. And what about traditionalists who refuse to accept the validity of another's path?
When it comes to children?
I don't have any children, and of course I have grand ideas of how I would raise them and nightmarish ideas about how I might fuck them up for all eternity. On the other hand, I once was a child who suffered intense indoctrination. It was not as militant as the kids shown in
Jesus Camp, but it was no less pervasive in every aspect of my life. The hang ups there may never go away completely, and the transition from that "old life" to my "new life" was a rocky one psychologically.
The truth of the matter is, most children love their religion when they're small. It's what mommy and daddy love, after all, and sometimes it can be filled with fun stories, decorations, and songs. The pagan paths certainly have no lack of those! I hope that pagan parents are being open and honest with their children and, when the kids are old enough, will let them freely explore what the rest of the religious world has to offer.
When kids are indoctrinated so fiercely, one of two things can happen. The first is that they will live up to the vast amounts of responsibility placed upon them; the second is that they won't. And when they can't, rebellion occurs.
But what if they can? From what I saw in the film, I can't imagine these kids growing up to be what their parents and ministers expect from them. I see them becoming something else. Something worse. When Christianity has been twisted this far and fed to children, who knows how much farther they will twist it by the time they've grown up? Who knows what battles these "warriors" will bring?
RhetoricOne thing that I noticed right off the bat, and it didn't cease throughout the entire film, was a heavy reliance on rhetoric from the ministers (and the children who did some preaching, too). Becky, the founder and organizer of the camp, managed to talk to a group of children and their parents for a matter of minutes
without actually saying anything. And without any real content, without any real teaching, without any application of scripture, the entire audience was swept up in an intense emotional response.
Comparing this to my own childhood I can see just how easy it is for church leaders (at local or national levels) to place triggers on their congregation. This is most easily done with catch phrases, egregious use of holy names (God, Jesus, Jehovah), and rhetorical questions with only one "spiritually correct" answer. When you hear the catch phrase, you have an immediate response in your heart and mind. When God's name is placed on something, it must be His truth. And, of course, if everyone else has the same answer, it must be the right one.
Pagan authors and bloggers use rhetoric quite a bit, but not in much the same way. It is much easier to speak in generalities, especially when your audience is as diverse as any pagan audience is likely to be. The difference is that we (for the most part) make it clear that we are expressing opinions, that we want others to express theirs, and that these opinions do not come from GOD and do not comprise the ONE TRUE WAY.
Once again (and this is, of course, only my opinion), the place where I see this kind of speaking/teaching getting us in trouble is in smaller groups like covens, groves, etc. One or two leaders or highly influential members can easily (sometimes unwittingly) set up this same kind of situation. When none of the answers to your questions contain practical information, or that information is always the same, this could be a bad sign. When leaders refuse to examine teachings and practices despite the pleadings of other members, there is
definitely a problem.
Jesus ComplexThe kids in
Jesus Camp are told again and again that it is their job to change the world. They have been chosen by Christ as the generation to 'take back America.' Quite a responsibility. And the evangelical M.O. is to shove Jesus down your throat until you believe.
I'm sure this doesn't seem at all familiar to anyone.
Far from being immune to the Jesus Complex, pagans seem
especially susceptible to it. We have sloughed off our inferiority, realized how much potential we have, and recognized the same divine spark within us that the masters had. That's great! That's what the masters wanted! But even Jesus
didn't force people to listen to his message. In fact, he admonished his apostles to walk away from opposition, to dust off their feet as they left the town that refused to hear, and to never come back.*
Obviously, pagans don't go around evangelizing. This is not the issue. But too many of us claim guru status without merit. Too many of us can't shut our mouths long enough to actually hear the person we are trying to help (save!) and understand their problem. Too many of us tout our religion or tradition or teaching as "TRUTH." Too many of us simply cannot help blabbing our ideas about where they are not welcome.
Many pagan faiths teach that everyone has a voice with equal right to be heard. Well, when everyone talks at the same time all you get is noise. We have the opportunity to sing together in unity as the Choir of Life, but we deny it on every turn. We can each be a part of the harmony, and we can each have a solo or two, but, damn it, what's the point of
singing in a group if you don't know how to
be in a group?
As a side note, New Agers have a similar complex with their children, as noted on
this Blog o' Gnosis post:
There is a sort of New Age parallel to the evangelical message that today’s children are Christ’s army: the whole “Indigo child” movement.... They’ve been raised to be total narcissists, believe the world revolves around them, have never been taught basic social etiquette, and have no respect for any authority but their own. In short, they’re as much a worry as the Bible-thumpers coming out of the Christian evangelical movement.
We should make sure that we don't allow our children (or
ourselves) to become such a worry, as well.
End of Part 1So, the title of this post doesn't make sense yet. I'll get to that next time. For the moment, let's all think about what we can learn to do and not do from our Christian neighbors. Even the radical evangelicals are here to teach and learn their lessons.
-Jonah
*My scripture recall is pretty fuzzy these days. If anyone reminds me where this is in the Bible, I'll put it on here.